Judge:
Jean Lucas
1st place Entry #2
2nd place
Entry #3
3rd place Entry #1
4th place
Entry #4
Placings 2,3,1,4
Two is over three In general
appearance he has the advantage in feet and legs
especially rear legs set when viewed from the side and
strength of pasterns front and rear. Also he has more
fullness in the crops
Three over one general appearance
he has more level top in the chine and the loin.
He is tighter in the shoulders. In body capacity he is
deeper and wider throughout.
One over four these two bucks are
really similar.
One has more stature over four. I would commend
four for his correct rear legs when viewed from the side
and rear.
|
Judge:
Todd Biddle
1st place Entry #3
2nd place Entry #5
3rd place Entry #2
4th place
Entry #1
5th place Entry #4
Placing 3-5-2-1-4
In our Mini Nubian buck two year old class, #3 has an
advantage in general appearance. He has more
correct breed type not only to his head and ear, but
also in his strength of bone and mass. In body
capacity, he is a much deeper ribbed buck with more
width to his chest.
In second place, we have a second generation Nubian who
does not show correct breed type. However, he is
the more correct in general appearance than the
remainder of the class which is why I have placed him
here. When you compare him to two he is more
correct in the blending and structure of the front end,
topline, rump, and feet and legs.
#2 over #1 is a
body capacity placing. #2 has a lot more substance
of bone, width of chest, depth of heart girth, depth to
his rear rib, and development of his barrel.
At the bottom of the class, #1 places over #4 in general
appearance with more correct breed type to the head with
less control of the ear and a longer ear as well as just
being smoother throughout comparatively speaking.
#4 will be commended for his sharp withers.
|