Judge:
Jean Lucas
1st place Entry #3
2nd place Entry #1
3rd place Entry #2
Placings 3, 1, 2
I am placing three over one in
mammary system. The height and width of the rear udder
and fore udder extension. She also appears more
capacious. She will yield to the depth of chest floor to
1.
One is placing over two for the
advantage she has in dairy character, she is sharper,
more angular and open throughout. In mammary system she
has a more capacious mammary system with more height and
width to the rear udder
Three should be commended for body
capacity. She is deeper and wider and more powerful
throughout.
|
Judge:
Todd Biddle
1st place Entry #1
2nd place Entry #3
3rd place Entry #2
Placing 1-3-2
An interesting class of Mini Aged Nubian does. There are a
lot of tradeoffs in this class.
#1 is placing over #3 in general appearance. She is stronger
on her feet and legs and smoother in the front end at
the junction of the point of elbow and chest floor.
I am going to give her the edge in mammary as well as I
am going to discriminate against our #3 doe for having a
twisted udder. When I view #3 in side profile, you
can see the one teat is slightly forward of the other
(in theory the two teats on both sides of the udder
should be aligned). This is a hard call to make
from a picture, but I feel the unbalance of mammary in
#3 is a structural issue of the mammary system.
However, in my bottom pair, I am placing #3 over #2 as she has a
lot more capacity to both the fore and rear udder and
she excels in dairy strength showing a lot more will to
milk with less excessive body fleshing.
#2 will be
commended for her width and power throughout.
|